Author: schwartz1b2dde10920

  • The Thing with Feathers

    Rachelle Schwartz


    “I am no bird; and no net ensnares me.”


    In these words by Charlotte Bronte, Jane Eyre declares with audacious authority the individuality and free will that she, as a “free human being” inherently possesses and has the right to. Using the comparison of a bird is not uncommon in discussions of freedom (sometimes, I have even believed it overused), but here, it stood out to me. I have only recently begun to notice why.

    Here, Jane Eyre uses the bird to symbolize a lack of freedom. Traditionally, the wings and flight of birds have given them a sense of easy, unquestioned freedom. A simplicity: if they do not like where they are, they simply flap their feathers and go somewhere else. Charlotte Bronte’s use of birds is for the opposite purpose. Jane Eyre is not noticing the characteristic freedom of birds, she is noticing how easily this freedom is encaged, and how quickly liberation is stripped from the innocent and defenseless. She is not saying the bird does not deserve to be free, she is saying she refuses to have her rightful and inherent right to freedom be treated with that same kind of disrespect. She is separating herself from the perceived weakness of the bird. But this weakness is just that: perceived.

    In reality, birds are not much weaker than the rest
    of us. To have the freedom of flight requires something of the bird’s anatomy. They must be lightweight, so they have evolved to have hollow bones. People often take this to mean that the
    bones are easily broken. However, contrary to popular belief, birds are not fragile creatures. Some research shows bird bones to be even stronger than those of land animals in some ways.
    Maya Angelou notices this strength with her use of the bird metaphor.

    Birds sing all the time, even when there seems to be nothing to sing about. I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings and its poetic counterpart, Caged Bird, answer the question of what a creature born to fly, but forced to stand behind the bars of a cage, wings clipped and talons tied, could have to sing about. What art
    can be made from the air of imprisonment? Angelou writes:


    “The caged bird sings
    with a fearful trill
    of things unknown
    but longed for still
    and his tune is heard
    on the distant hill
    for the caged bird
    sings of freedom.”


    When captured, the last means of escape is through their downy throats. Their song is not a song of celebration like the birds outside the windows, it is an act of protest. She specifies that
    this bird was born in a cage by saying it has never known freedom; still, the bird hungers for it. Freedom is a more primal urge than I think we realize. Something within us is hypnotically taken with it, even if we have never experienced the kind of freedom we are craving.

    This reminded me of Suzanne Collins’s use of the Mockingjay, a fictional bird, in The Hunger Games as a symbol for the political rebellion aimed at taking down a corrupt government. Most of the characters fighting against the injustice of their government have never known any other way of life, but they are very aware that things are not right, and far from fair. Harper
    Lee used them to represent the unprovoked killing of a nonviolent thing in To Kill a Mockingbird. This is probably on of the more famous examples, but uses of bird metaphors in literature are endless. They are symbols of hope, peace, and resistance. Whatever they come to represent, though, they all have something in common: they are acknowledging a certain trade off in belonging to a society. There is a certain amount of wing-trimming we all must do to remain within the confines of security. We cannot dance naked in public, we cannot eat fruit from trees that do not belong to us, we cannot eat at all actually until we give somebody money. Even at the most basic, peaceful, and nonviolent level, living in a society centered on ownership and monetization can never allow for real freedom because in
    this world you cannot do anything without money, a deed, or a weapon.

    Humans seem to have a an interest, an envy, for the freedom of the bird. How often do we hear characters express a wish to be a bird when we read or watch television. I was a little embarrassed with myself one evening last November when I found myself absentmindedly musing on my own longing to be a bird. The evening was crisp. One could no longer ignore the imminence of winter, or the way it crushed the orange embers of past hopes into cooling ashes, waiting patiently for disposal. I insisted on sitting outside as I did my homework, even though it was more than a little chilly, because I knew it would be one of the last times I could do so before the snow came and the freeze settled deep into the dirt. Instead of looking down at the plethora of final exams, projects, and papers on my dull laptop screen of due dates and time charts, my eyes were on the sky, and I didn’t particularly mind. There were a few birds taking turns swooping and twirling above the fountain outside the library. They seemed to be dancing, carefree and playful. I wanted nothing more in that moment than to be just like that: detached from the worries of the ground, in a complete and utter lack of walls, the openness of the cool air in my throat, completely alive and, somehow, completely unconcerned with that fact. I was embarrassed at first to be the vessel of such a commonplace desire. I felt pedestrian and childish. But why should I be ashamed of wanting something just because everyone else wants it too? We all want freedom for a reason. We deserve to have it. I envied those birds so much that evening.

    Birds have come to represent so many things for humans because we see so much of ourselves in them. They show us ourselves from many directions like a room of mirrors. They represent our freedom, our oppression, our rebellion, our peace, our potential, our reality. To cage them is inherently symbolic because they themselves are symbolic. Just as Harper Lee attests in To Kill a Mockingbird, the killing of a sacred thing is a statement in itself. It has implications beyond the isolated act. It involves more than the bird and the bullet. The bird metaphor is not overdone; I am no longer ashamed to be writing just one of many accolades to the birds.

    We sympathize with birds so easily because the resilience of their spirit mimics the indomitability of our own. It echoes with something somber and restrained, but ready to soar. Emily Dickinson said, “Hope is the thing with feathers – That perches in the soul.” This language of “perching” is important. The bird is staying still, the bird is latching to something; but it is staying there for a reason, and it can leave whenever it wants. Suzanne Collins’s villain, President Snow, said that a little hope is good, but too much was dangerous because it gave people incentive to rise against that which oppressed them. Hope is rebellious. Hope is how we choose freedom even when it is not within grasp; it’s the freest thing about us.

  • Is It Just Me, Or is Mary Shelley a Prophet?

    Rachelle Schwartz

    I will warn you now, this is not a safe space for AI users, supporters, and advancers. And to anyone who is not yet afraid of the future of AI, you will find this to be irritatingly melodramatic, and maybe it is. However, there is certainly something to be said for a technological innovation that changes our culture as drastically as artificial intelligence software has in such a short span of time, so I will say it as melodramatically as I please.

    So we have all seen Jurassic Park (1993), right? Well, do you remember that part where Jeff Goldblum’s sexy scientist character says, “God creates man. Man destroys God. Man creates dinosaurs.” Well the situation we are in with this sudden push for AI is pretty much that, just replace dinosaurs with artificial intelligence. Oh, and after, “Man creates artificial intelligence,” add that man also crowns artificial intelligence as king and sacrifices himself to his own creation. Okay so maybe it’s not exactly like Jurassic Park, but close enough. The threat posed by the widespread incorporation of artificial intelligence may not be as gruesome as being eaten by a T-rex, but it is certainly another example of the human quest to control and create life backfiring.

    Now this is where Mary Shelley comes in. Even if you haven’t read Frankenstein, you probably understand the basic premise: a young, passionate scientist galvanizes a corpse into life in order to find a cure for death. This is the first part of the prophecy. In order to find a remedy for using our own brains, we have invented artificial brains to do the work of thinking and writing for us. We are “curing” a tedious part of our human existence by replacing it with a soulless placeholder which is not actually capable of matching our capacities in thinking nor in writing, but is convincing enough to pass. Victor abandoned his monster, and maybe we should too, but I suppose abandonment didn’t exactly work out for him. Eventually, his creation grows too intelligent and driven, killing all of Victor’s loved ones in a quest for revenge that led to Victor’s own demise after a prolonged chase through the alps (spoiler alert).

    I am not saying AI is going to kill all of your friends and family, but you never know. Even if not, this new shortcut is certainly taking things from us that we value very deeply. Our ability to think, being one of them. Artificial intelligence technology was meant to be a servant that made the dull parts of the work easier. However, it has become a Frankenstein’s monster in its own right as it’s data base continually grows and it’s developers expand their reach beyond our control. The bigwigs behind things like ChatGPT, Grok, and a million others, are using our own laziness against us. New AI models are appearing everywhere, implemented in ways that insist upon their use. Worse still, it seems to require less and less insistence as the population becomes all too eager to find the easiest way around even the most mundane tasks.

    This tsunami of AI generation has flooded into every plane imaginable. From fiction novels to journalistic articles, and even personal transmissions. AI developers want us to use their technology to write our emails, finish our sentences, and create our social media posts for us. If we let the use of generative AI infiltrate all of the ways we express ourselves, the opportunity for human connection becomes even more limited. While AI was supposed to be our faithful servant, it feels we instead are the ones serving its already massive, unethically-sourced database, as well as the pockets of those behind it. There are real cases of AI developers feeding rare books to the AI to be digitally digested and destroyed. This sounds like dystopian science fiction, but it’s not. When we use AI, it’s algorithm processes our personal style into its ever-growing pool of information. Its developers exploit us for our human traits every time we type a prompt or response into one of their systems. These algorithms take everything human that we give it and jam it into a giant meat grinder that cranks out overused syntactical patterns and undistinguished correctness.

    Humans invented AI and marveled at their ability to create something so intelligent. Victor also marveled at the functioning of his patchwork cadaver before things got a little too real for him. The same humans have now found themselves subordinate to the creation which they gave power to by placing efficiency on a higher pedestal than progress. Who could have seen this coming? Mary Shelley, that’s who. It is the same creator/creation dynamic as we see in Frankenstein, only instead of being praised as a God as he intended, Victor was destroyed in the name of righteous retribution. But maybe that part of the prophecy is not so far off either.

    Victor Frankenstein becoming disgusted at his creation. Illustration from the frontispiece of the 1831 edition. Steel engraving (993 x 71mm) to the revised edition of Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, published by Colburn and Bentley, London 1831. The novel was first published in 1818.

    If you ask me, this is a more sinister sort of harm than what Frankenstein’s monster inflicted. The monster may have been gruesome, and murder is rarely justifiable, but at least he had a cause. At least he was seeking revenge with passion, something AI can never be programmed to understand. At least he was not forcing Victor to read AI slop Instagram captions. At least Victor was given the respect of being destroyed by something that had thoughts and feelings. If AI is to ever destroy mankind, it will be the result of statistical calculations. There will be no distressed monologues or pained wails wrenched from the depths of our destroyer’s being. There will be a cursor pretending to consider something and a corny one liner: “It’s not the age of AI, it’s the age of human annihilation.”

    Humans intend to usher in a future of ease and comfort in our tasks. They refer to AI as a “super intelligence.” An aid in our journey to superior consciousness. In reality, we are sacrificing everything from physical resources, human artifacts, personal histories, and our own lived experiences to the anonymous altar of something we created. In attempting to advance our species through unnaturally efficient means, we have rendered ourselves incompetent and useless. Who wants to hire a human when the newest AI model is so much cheaper, faster, and easier? Who wants to think for themselves when Grok can do it for them? Who wants to write a heartfelt message to the love of their life when ChatGPT is so good at sounding like it cares?

    But cutting out every meaningful part of the process is not efficiency. What is the point in producing all this text if what makes writing important is no longer valued? There can be no progress with generated text; it just recycles the few resources we don’t need to conserve: our thoughts, language, and expression. We are not ushering in a future of super intelligence; rather, it is a future in which everything that makes humanity outstanding is devalued. The only intelligence benefitting here is the software. Even those whose pockets are bursting at the seams from all the profits of generative artificial intelligence are not getting any smarter. The use of AI makes us more dependent and less experienced while it has the opposite effect on the algorithm.

    Like the monster, AI software seems to be inescapable, undefeatable, and more human than we intended. But the real kicker is that the humans behind AI are a lot like Victor. That is, they are much closer to the true villains of the story than the computers we so often blame. Human greed, be it for power, money, or fame, is what drives this surge in artificial intelligence, just as it drove Victor to generate life where it no longer belonged. AI itself does not have any sort of bloodlust or desire to destroy us. In fact, these algorithms have no desires at all. They are technical marvels, but they will never have the capacity to feel anything even remotely close to bloodlust. That is something unique to creatures of flesh, just as so many other things that we value in art and writing. Even the level of advancement we are reaching with AI can never compare with the miracle we are born with: consciousness. Artificial intelligence will never be better than you at writing because it cannot possibly think on the level that you can. The only people who want you to believe otherwise are those with something to gain.

  • Losing Your Religion? Fear Not, Cherry-Picking Your Own is Chic.

    Rachelle Schwartz

    Growing up in the odd situation of being a little Mennonite girl in rural Ohio makes for some pretty interesting stories, but it was no fairy tale. I was slowly beginning to realize that something about my family did not seem to integrate with the wider world I was being introduced to. That is, I was noticing that we were really weird. Worse still, I felt like I was even weirder than the rest of my family. I remember sitting in church pews every Sunday as our preacher went on tirades about the threat of secular society and our father hissed at us to be quiet. All I could manage to do during those grating sermons was look at the stiff necks in front of me as they nodded their routine agreement and wonder if they actually believed this nonsense or if they were all just pretending like I was.

    Later, my older sister helped me repent on our back porch so that I could “be saved.” I understood the premise of what I was doing, but I failed to see how reading a prewritten line from our homeschool Bible packet was going to convince Jesus that I deserved to be let into heaven. I was not interested. However, I read what I was told, let her tell me I had found my salvation, and went inside feeling like the exact same sinner I had been when I woke up that morning.

    Later, I would learn that there were more religions than the Mennonite Christianity I had been raised in. This complicated things further.

    “How do we know that the Bible is right?” I asked this question to the same sister who directed me in the task of my salvation. I was not asking it with curiosity; I did not believe there was any answer she could give me. I was arguing.

    “Christianity has the most followers of any religion. It’s the most popular.” She was annoyed. Insulted that I had even asked the question, and embarrassed at her lack of a satisfying answer.

    I don’t remember my exact rebuttal, but it was somewhere along the lines of how popularity did not equate rightness, how all religions are just as likely to be true because they were all sourced from some mystic/messiah that one group decided to trust and follow. All religions make claims. Who are we to decide what to believe when the evidence it all pertains to is so far buried in ancient history? Or something like that. Luckily, I was in elementary school, so no one had to take my questions seriously. But boy oh boy, that did not stop me from asking them.

    I do not intend to write some self-serving testimony to my struggle growing up Mennonite with a brain that was very bad at believing what it was supposed to. What I mean to get at is where this struggle brought me. I tried to be a Christian again in my teens after a period of unofficial agnosticism, but I found myself cherry-picking the Bible (a big no no, apparently) so as to reconcile it with the rest of my values (values such as kissing other girls in the church camp bathroom). However, this dissonance between me and the rest of the Christian faith and believers was greater than my skills of compromise, so I was back on the search for something a little closer to home. I learned about Buddhism, Paganism, even the new age spirituality my mother practiced after she left the church. All of them had parts that I found undeniably appealing, but they also contained features that I couldn’t quite get behind.

    And then I realized something revolutionary: I didn’t have to choose. I did not have to make a selection from the preexisting options. I could create my own option. And no, I do not mean starting a new religious cult with which to terrorize the locals. The whole point of my choosing to not choose was that it was just for me. I prefer to do what I do best: cherry-pick. I let my fickleness guide me into whatever feels right, not worrying about boxes or labels. I love Jesus’s preachings of unconditional love, so I follow them. I love Buddha’s philosophy of presence, so I practice it. I love the Pagan tradition of rituals, so I bless the tap water before I use it to wash my face. You do not have to be a priest to work miracles, and you don’t have to be enlightened to see them. I have switched the purpose of religion and spirituality in my life away from being something that saves me from damnation, and rather something that brings me closer to the open air outside my window. I bow to my yoga mat before I roll it up just because it feels deeply right in my spine. I conduct rituals with clean palms and gleaming soap suds in the shower. And the best part is I don’t have to explain anything because I am not asking anyone to agree.

    This doesn’t mean I don’t draw from others. Below is an excerpt from the poem that helped me greatly in putting together some notion of spirituality when left to my own devices. A link to the entire work will be left below, as well as a truly spectacular musical rendition by Buffy Saint Marie, which never fails to carve a new depth into my personal understanding of things.


    The naked God did live
    This I mean to whisper to my mind
    This I mean to laugh within my mind
    This I mean my mind to serve
    Til’ service is but magic
    Moving through the world
    And mind itself is magic
    Coursing through the flesh
    And flesh itself is magic
    Dancing on a clock
    And time itself
    The magic length of God

    This excerpt is particularly relevant to what it is I am trying to communicate through this garbled blasphemy. In this poem, the authors (Leonard Cohen, Sarah Perkins, and Ian Jackson) use the terms God and Magic as if they are allowed to exist at the same time. This sheds a little light on an old memory in which I asked my grandmother what the difference was between the miracles God works and the magic from movies and books. Why can one be possible and the other can’t? (Middle school me had just read Harry Potter and was desperate to prove it wasn’t impossible to live the life I yearned for more desperately than eternal communion with my savior). I had no idea that magic was considered a bad word by the people who raised me, and I still don’t see why it should be.

    It is this gatekeeping mindset of singulars that I reject: one correct way to believe, one correct way to practice. God cannot exist at the same time as astral projection or Allah or Pagan spirits, and never ever at the same time as Magic. Well, I love Pixie Hollow too much to accept its fictionality. Unfortunately, I also loved going to church at nighttime as the snow flurries in the dark windows, and I put on my angel costume to make my very first (ten-second) stage appearance in the church Christmas play. And I also love to meditate with my back on the grass and spend the rest of the night itchy and splendid. And I won’t be told to choose only one, because then I’d be cherry-picking my own love and interests. And the only cherry-picking that is not chic is the self-defeating kind.

    Cohen, Leanord, et al. God is Alive Magic is Afoot. Galileo Multimedia, 2000. https://www.leonardcohenfiles.com/book29.html

    Buffy Sainte-Marie. God is Alive Magic is Afoot. Vanguard Records, 1969. https://share.google/L505eneuvyfyC9ikK

  • Am I Crazy, or Is Ken the Hero of the Barbie Movie? Let’s Discuss.

    Alyssa Derry

    If you were one of the millions of Americans who went to see the Barbie movie in theaters when it first exploded onto the cinematic scene in 2023, the intense pink branding and name of the film probably had you convinced Barbie would be its hero. That is one interpretation of the film, to be sure, but I left theaters humming a different tune… namely, “I’m Just Ken.”

    Though most of the film focuses on Barbie and her journey from smiling plastic ideal to flesh-and-blood, complete-with-cellulite woman, there’s no denying that Ryan Gosling’s Ken has a habit of stealing the show every time he bumbles onto the screen. From the film’s beginning, his character arc is every bit as enticing, if not more so, than Barbie’s. It’s also a whole lot messier, if you ask me, which is part of why I believe that Ken is the Barbie film’s hero.

    Here’s the part where you shake your head at your computer monitor, close the tab, and rave about how absurd this take is, but hear me out. Ken is the one, first off, who performs his own power ballad, not Barbie – that’s hero behavior. Ken is the one who goes off to literal battle (albeit on a floatie toy) and returns, battered but improved by his odyssey. Ken is the one with the grandiose gestures and box office-shattering dramatic scenes; Barbie is not.

    But more than that, Ken is the one whose arc more closely resembles a hero’s traditional narrative. At the beginning of the film, Ken’s life is pretty dismal. As a Ken in Barbieland, he is treated as an afterthought who cannot possibly measure up to Barbie’s effortless excellence. He’s part of a demographic that the majority wants to laugh at and then coldly dismiss – sound familiar, women in the real world? In other words, he’s an underdog, with a cause to fight for and a point to prove. Barbie, by contrast, is part of the majority doing the laughing and dismissing; she is kind to Ken in a surface-level way, of course (“Hi, Ken!”), but she doesn’t take his feelings seriously. In almost any other film, Ken would be the character the director wants us to root for.

    From there, he rises up against the government he feels oppressed by, a trademark of young adult heroes such as Katniss Everdeen and Tris Prior – two women who, like Ken, rise up against an oppressive government. Ken may be a man (or man-coded doll, anyway), but his oppression is very similar to what these women experience. Of course, unlike Tris and Katniss, he fights the status quo by turning women into his personal maids, which makes us hate him a little, but the point still stands that Ken is trying to make a difference in the world he lives in. On his journey to make change, he realizes that he has gone about it all wrong – that enslaving women won’t make him happy and that he can only find true happiness by embracing that Ken is him, a realization that hits him harder than the cardboard waves do at the beginning of the movie.

    When combined, these themes of being the underdog and having to grow in order to have a happy ending make Ken’s narrative one of a traditional hero. Barbie may be an underdog in the real world, but she starts her story at the top of society, making her the enemy in just about any other narrative. As for her growth, although she does learn to embrace imperfection in her journey to become human, she ends the movie wearing the same smile even at the gynecologist. Her story is just a little too perfect to really fit into our view of traditional heroism.

    This isn’t to say we don’t love Barbie or root for her – of course we do. Her vulnerable exploration of her own humanity and mortality are deeply moving to watch. But where Barbie is quiet, Ken is loud. Where Margot Robbie is dubbed too flawless to ever feel insecure by the movie’s narrator, Ryan Gosling is making a total fool out of himself as Ken. Where Barbie is holding hands with her creator in a void as a melancholic track plays, Ken is performing an elaborate choreographed dance alongside his other Kens and singing the song himself. Ken is the one I hear referenced in casual conversation and Instagram captions; “Not to be confused with lifeguard, which is a common misconception,” my friends recite from memory. Where Barbie is inspiring some to dress in pink, Ken’s very name is sported on hoodies.

    Barbie’s story is inspiring. It’s moving. But Ken’s struggle to discover who he is in a world he feels ignored within rings a lot truer, more memorable, and even more impactful to me as a hero’s story. An imperfect story, yes, even a really problematic one at times. (Don’t think I’m letting the enslaving women thing slide.) But the best heroes have rocky journeys! And Ken is no exception. If anything, he’s a comfort, telling audiences that you can make mistakes and still deserve to be celebrated and to love your own goofy, misguided, ridiculous self – and that’s what makes him a hero to me.

  • What’s the Deal with Allan?

    Zachery Armstrong

    If you’ve seen Barbie, you probably remember Allan. The quirky, one-of-a-kind guy played by Michael Cera, who just so happens to fit into all of Ken’s clothes. Just a weird little side character. I mean, who doesn’t love Michael Cera? But really, though, what’s his deal?

    The Kens are clearly analogous for men in the real world, right? And the Barbies are analogous for women. So, what about Allan? Is he a man? Is he a woman? Why not neither? Or maybe both?

    One possible answer is to view him as a queer-coded, or at the very least as a gender nonconforming character. He isn’t explicitly made to be masculine or feminine, and he doesn’t really fit in with the Kens or the Barbies. He doesn’t pine after the Barbies on the beach, or really seem to have any romantic interests at all. The only other character that’s remotely similar to him is Weird Barbie, a similarly unusual and queer-coded outcast of Barbieland. It seems like the narrator, Helen Mirren, put it best: Allan is one of a kind.

    But what does it mean for a character to be gender nonconforming in a place like Barbieland? Well, he doesn’t feel any kind of pressure to fit into the expectations of the other dolls. He doesn’t have to endlessly fight and toil with the Kens over the Barbies’ affections, and he doesn’t have any other Allans with whom he has to share an identity. He is completely free to be himself, and only himself. Sounds kinda nice, right? With all of the gender conflict in the film, a character that exists outside of gender in and of itself is a breath of fresh air.

    I think it’s possible that Director Greta Gerwig is using Allan as a kind of ambassador for queerness in Barbieland, demonstrating how cutting loose from the rigid confines of binary gender can actually be pretty cool. The Kens endlessly suffer from their own gender, insecure in how they compare to the others, always trying to be the most Ken Ken possible. But why? Wouldn’t it be so much easier to just be themselves? To pursue whatever happens to interest them at any given moment, independent of their identity as a Ken? I think Allan makes the answer to that question obvious – it is easier to just be yourself.

    By Warner Bros./Mattel – Promotional still from the film

    In a way, Allan is a hero. Maybe not in the traditional sense, triumphantly charging into battle to force change into motion, but in a subtler way: A kind of peaceful, quiet resistance. But wait, doesn’t he get into a physical brawl with a group of construction Kens, ultimately culminating in him choking one of them out with a shovel? Oh yeah, he does. Maybe a little bit of violence is warranted now and then.

    Who knows, maybe one day we’ll all occupy a genderless society, where being something as blank and undefined as Allan is the default option. Or maybe not. Maybe our society’s stance on gender has plateaued, having arrived at its final destination. Regardless, I think we could all stand to be just a little more like Allan.

  • Barbie Is a Messy Breakup Note to the Color Pink

    Anne Alexsonshk

    The Barbie movie was one of the most successful films of 2023, bringing in $26.1 million. Enjoying the pink and glitter-full experience, the audience may have overlooked what might have been the boldest breakup of the century—not between people, but between Barbie and something historic: The color pink. A relationship that’s been going on for some 66 years might finally be over because of one movie. Despite the hard-core Barbie fangirls and pink enthusiasts, Barbie is low-key dumping the color pink. In Greta Gerwig’s film, we get to see the 21st-century version of the doll, one that represents the ideal of fashion, femininity, and, of course, pink, or so I thought. I’ve watched the movie many times and only felt pink and empowered (or, pink power). It wasn’t until I took a closer look at the ending that I realized the Barbie movie is a breakup letter, one that Mattel tried to cover up with sparkles and glitter.

    Before we get on to spilling the tea, let’s look back at the relationship’s history. When did Barbie become pink, and how did this color define the doll’s identity? It all started with one woman named Ruth Handler, who founded Mattel with her husband in 1954. Then, in 1955, Barbie’s logo became pink. It was the start of a new love story, though Barbie didn’t actually wear the color pink until 1977, when Superstar Barbie was released. After that, Barbie only became pinker and pinker, so much so that you could not think of Barbie without imagining the color pink. I mean, there’s even a shade named after her—#(E0218a), or, “Barbie Pink.”

    In Barbieland the sun is always shining and pink is around every corner. This movie is very pink-centric, so much so that the making of the film even caused a shortage of Barbie Pink in 2022. I mean, even in Barbieland, as they’re showing all these beautiful sights, we hear the song Pink, by Lizzo, in the background. A repeated lyric is “We like other colors, but pink just looks so good on us.” But underneath all the jokes, there is something serious: Barbieland, signified by pink, is a fantasy. This is why the real-world hits Barbie so hard, shaking her worldview.

    We see Barbie turn from a bright and bubbly woman into a sad, stressed, and confused one. Her attitude toward pink starts to shift, especially after meeting Sasha, who challenges Barbie’s rose-tinted view of the world. Barbieland, after all, is not a reflection of the real women’s status in the real world. As Barbie understands this, she starts to see these cracks within her own system. This truly doesn’t change until the latter part of the movie. Her transformation from wanting to go back to the pink-centric Barbieland to wanting to live as a real woman starts as the Kens take over Barbieland. Gerwig dresses Barbie in pink in almost every scene. As the movie progresses through the crisis, though, she goes from pink to pastels with accents of pink, then a faded yellow, and finally the Blues and Grays of the real world. The most striking moment of change in Barbie is once she meets Ruth in Barbieland. After peace is restored, with the Barbies back on top in their postfeminist fantasy world, Barbie explains that she doesn’t feel like Barbie anymore. Ruth offers a chance to become human and be a creator instead of a creation.

    In the end, the gains of living and creating in the real world is enough to make up for living in a patriarchal world. That’s when the narrator says, “so Barbie left behind the pastels and plastics of BarbieLand for the pastels and plastics of Los Angeles.” Aside from the joke at L.A.’s expense, this movement into real life symbolizes her crossover and rejection of BarbieLand in its ideals—including the pink that is its symbol. Notably, Barbie wears a yellow dress throughout this scene.

    This ultimate rejection of the color pink and the fantasy for which it stands seems pretty important, so why is it so overlooked? Well, one of the reasons is the marketing campaign that accompanied the film. Mattel marketed almost everything surrounding this movie with pink, pink, and pink. They made brand deals with companies such as Valentino, Armani, Chanel, Hugo Boss, and Ralph Lauren. Even Burger King got in on it with a pink-topped burger. Barbie—and pink–became the new fab and you could see it in every store. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but it certainly didn’t reflect the message of the movie. Like Ken, pink in Barbie is something best left to the fantasy world of Barbieland. Now somebody tell that to Burger King.