Rachelle Schwartz

Growing up in the odd situation of being a little Mennonite girl in rural Ohio makes for some pretty interesting stories, but it was no fairy tale. I was slowly beginning to realize that something about my family did not seem to integrate with the wider world I was being introduced to. That is, I was noticing that we were really weird. Worse still, I felt like I was even weirder than the rest of my family. I remember sitting in church pews every Sunday as our preacher went on tirades about the threat of secular society and our father hissed at us to be quiet. All I could manage to do during those grating sermons was look at the stiff necks in front of me as they nodded their routine agreement and wonder if they actually believed this nonsense or if they were all just pretending like I was.
Later, my older sister helped me repent on our back porch so that I could “be saved.” I understood the premise of what I was doing, but I failed to see how reading a prewritten line from our homeschool Bible packet was going to convince Jesus that I deserved to be let into heaven. I was not interested. However, I read what I was told, let her tell me I had found my salvation, and went inside feeling like the exact same sinner I had been when I woke up that morning.
Later, I would learn that there were more religions than the Mennonite Christianity I had been raised in. This complicated things further.
“How do we know that the Bible is right?” I asked this question to the same sister who directed me in the task of my salvation. I was not asking it with curiosity; I did not believe there was any answer she could give me. I was arguing.
“Christianity has the most followers of any religion. It’s the most popular.” She was annoyed. Insulted that I had even asked the question, and embarrassed at her lack of a satisfying answer.
I don’t remember my exact rebuttal, but it was somewhere along the lines of how popularity did not equate rightness, how all religions are just as likely to be true because they were all sourced from some mystic/messiah that one group decided to trust and follow. All religions make claims. Who are we to decide what to believe when the evidence it all pertains to is so far buried in ancient history? Or something like that. Luckily, I was in elementary school, so no one had to take my questions seriously. But boy oh boy, that did not stop me from asking them.
I do not intend to write some self-serving testimony to my struggle growing up Mennonite with a brain that was very bad at believing what it was supposed to. What I mean to get at is where this struggle brought me. I tried to be a Christian again in my teens after a period of unofficial agnosticism, but I found myself cherry-picking the Bible (a big no no, apparently) so as to reconcile it with the rest of my values (values such as kissing other girls in the church camp bathroom). However, this dissonance between me and the rest of the Christian faith and believers was greater than my skills of compromise, so I was back on the search for something a little closer to home. I learned about Buddhism, Paganism, even the new age spirituality my mother practiced after she left the church. All of them had parts that I found undeniably appealing, but they also contained features that I couldn’t quite get behind.
And then I realized something revolutionary: I didn’t have to choose. I did not have to make a selection from the preexisting options. I could create my own option. And no, I do not mean starting a new religious cult with which to terrorize the locals. The whole point of my choosing to not choose was that it was just for me. I prefer to do what I do best: cherry-pick. I let my fickleness guide me into whatever feels right, not worrying about boxes or labels. I love Jesus’s preachings of unconditional love, so I follow them. I love Buddha’s philosophy of presence, so I practice it. I love the Pagan tradition of rituals, so I bless the tap water before I use it to wash my face. You do not have to be a priest to work miracles, and you don’t have to be enlightened to see them. I have switched the purpose of religion and spirituality in my life away from being something that saves me from damnation, and rather something that brings me closer to the open air outside my window. I bow to my yoga mat before I roll it up just because it feels deeply right in my spine. I conduct rituals with clean palms and gleaming soap suds in the shower. And the best part is I don’t have to explain anything because I am not asking anyone to agree.
This doesn’t mean I don’t draw from others. Below is an excerpt from the poem that helped me greatly in putting together some notion of spirituality when left to my own devices. A link to the entire work will be left below, as well as a truly spectacular musical rendition by Buffy Saint Marie, which never fails to carve a new depth into my personal understanding of things.
The naked God did live
This I mean to whisper to my mind
This I mean to laugh within my mind
This I mean my mind to serve
Til’ service is but magic
Moving through the world
And mind itself is magic
Coursing through the flesh
And flesh itself is magic
Dancing on a clock
And time itself
The magic length of God
This excerpt is particularly relevant to what it is I am trying to communicate through this garbled blasphemy. In this poem, the authors (Leonard Cohen, Sarah Perkins, and Ian Jackson) use the terms God and Magic as if they are allowed to exist at the same time. This sheds a little light on an old memory in which I asked my grandmother what the difference was between the miracles God works and the magic from movies and books. Why can one be possible and the other can’t? (Middle school me had just read Harry Potter and was desperate to prove it wasn’t impossible to live the life I yearned for more desperately than eternal communion with my savior). I had no idea that magic was considered a bad word by the people who raised me, and I still don’t see why it should be.
It is this gatekeeping mindset of singulars that I reject: one correct way to believe, one correct way to practice. God cannot exist at the same time as astral projection or Allah or Pagan spirits, and never ever at the same time as Magic. Well, I love Pixie Hollow too much to accept its fictionality. Unfortunately, I also loved going to church at nighttime as the snow flurries in the dark windows, and I put on my angel costume to make my very first (ten-second) stage appearance in the church Christmas play. And I also love to meditate with my back on the grass and spend the rest of the night itchy and splendid. And I won’t be told to choose only one, because then I’d be cherry-picking my own love and interests. And the only cherry-picking that is not chic is the self-defeating kind.
Cohen, Leanord, et al. God is Alive Magic is Afoot. Galileo Multimedia, 2000. https://www.leonardcohenfiles.com/book29.html
Buffy Sainte-Marie. God is Alive Magic is Afoot. Vanguard Records, 1969. https://share.google/L505eneuvyfyC9ikK

Leave a Reply