What’s the Deal with Allan?

Zachery Armstrong

If you’ve seen Barbie, you probably remember Allan. The quirky, one-of-a-kind guy played by Michael Cera, who just so happens to fit into all of Ken’s clothes. Just a weird little side character. I mean, who doesn’t love Michael Cera? But really, though, what’s his deal?

The Kens are clearly analogous for men in the real world, right? And the Barbies are analogous for women. So, what about Allan? Is he a man? Is he a woman? Why not neither? Or maybe both?

One possible answer is to view him as a queer-coded, or at the very least as a gender nonconforming character. He isn’t explicitly made to be masculine or feminine, and he doesn’t really fit in with the Kens or the Barbies. He doesn’t pine after the Barbies on the beach, or really seem to have any romantic interests at all. The only other character that’s remotely similar to him is Weird Barbie, a similarly unusual and queer-coded outcast of Barbieland. It seems like the narrator, Helen Mirren, put it best: Allan is one of a kind.

But what does it mean for a character to be gender nonconforming in a place like Barbieland? Well, he doesn’t feel any kind of pressure to fit into the expectations of the other dolls. He doesn’t have to endlessly fight and toil with the Kens over the Barbies’ affections, and he doesn’t have any other Allans with whom he has to share an identity. He is completely free to be himself, and only himself. Sounds kinda nice, right? With all of the gender conflict in the film, a character that exists outside of gender in and of itself is a breath of fresh air.

I think it’s possible that Director Greta Gerwig is using Allan as a kind of ambassador for queerness in Barbieland, demonstrating how cutting loose from the rigid confines of binary gender can actually be pretty cool. The Kens endlessly suffer from their own gender, insecure in how they compare to the others, always trying to be the most Ken Ken possible. But why? Wouldn’t it be so much easier to just be themselves? To pursue whatever happens to interest them at any given moment, independent of their identity as a Ken? I think Allan makes the answer to that question obvious – it is easier to just be yourself.

By Warner Bros./Mattel – Promotional still from the film

In a way, Allan is a hero. Maybe not in the traditional sense, triumphantly charging into battle to force change into motion, but in a subtler way: A kind of peaceful, quiet resistance. But wait, doesn’t he get into a physical brawl with a group of construction Kens, ultimately culminating in him choking one of them out with a shovel? Oh yeah, he does. Maybe a little bit of violence is warranted now and then.

Who knows, maybe one day we’ll all occupy a genderless society, where being something as blank and undefined as Allan is the default option. Or maybe not. Maybe our society’s stance on gender has plateaued, having arrived at its final destination. Regardless, I think we could all stand to be just a little more like Allan.

Comments

Leave a Reply