Amanda Adams

I’m not from L.A. (Cleveland born and bred!) and have visited only a few times, so most of my associations with that city come from movies set there—great movies like Chinatown and L.A. Confidential, and even greater ones like Clueless. So last year when L.A. was dealing with the deadly and destructive wildfires, I thought about the Barbie movie of 2023. It might seem an odd bit of stream-of-consciousness wandering, but Greta Gerwig’s raucous and dense comedy is obsessed with environment, if not fires. One need only watch the first few minutes to see the care and attention given to the set design and imagined world of Barbie Land. Yet environment—the real environment—gets explicit mention only two times. One comes at the end, when Helen Mirren’s dry narrator jokes that “Barbie left behind the pastels and plastics of Barbie Land for the pastels and plastics of Los Angeles.” But the first one—when mean tween Sasha berates Barbie in front of Sasha’s friends for, among other things, “killing the planet with your glorification of rampant consumerism”—is the one that stuck with me.
Is Sasha right? Should we think of Barbie as, in fact, a contributor to environmental destruction or should we dismiss that charge as puberty-driven hyperbole? It can be, and probably is, both. Because we can draw a line between Barbie’s plastic, fossil-fuel-driven existence and the climate change that fueled those fires. To be clear, I’m not accusing our sweet, polymer-based Barbie of directly setting those fires (honestly, that seems like something Ken would do), but Barbie has long been and continues to be a cultural symbol on the subject, so stick with me.
Plastic’s fossil-fuel burning origins and their indestructibility (read: nonbiodegradability) come right out of the same decades as Barbie’s rise to fame. In fact, it is in precisely the post-WWII era that plastics began to dominate other materials for household items like glass or aluminum. After all, it is in 1967 when 1) Mattel, thriving despite the burgeoning counterculture, released its first celebrity Barbie (Twiggy) and 2) The Graduate was released, including a scene in which the main character gets some memorable one-word career advice: “Plastics.” In other words, Barbie (made of plastic) and plastic in general, rise to prominence at the same time. And plastics, made of crude oil, aren’t great for the environment in so many ways.
A conscientious film about this indestructible doll coming out in 2023 must and, I think, does take this issue seriously. In fact, Barbie presents a subtle, parallel environmental argument alongside its more prominent one about gender. Barbie’s final, existential choice to become a human woman and stop being an “idea” is an embrace of mortality and the fact that, as Barbie-creator Ruth Handler says, “humans only have one end.” For Barbie, the downside of facing eventual death is worth it to experience the highs and lows of human experience as well as the ability to be a thinking individual. Nothing captures this paradox better than her cheery last line, “I’m here to see my gynecologist!” A need for a doctor (a real one, not a plastic pop-up ambulance that treats Ken’s beach woes earlier in the movie) suggests a body that can falter and fail, but also a living body, which is why she’s so excited.
The film’s treatment of environment mirrors that journey. The plastic world of Barbie Land gives way to the “real world,” but it’s not a natural paradise, just like the real world is not a feminist utopia. Instead, like Barbie Land, real-world L.A. functions on plastic and fossil fuels, as cars and trucks are everywhere in the urban set (though the Ken’s Hummer is an EV). Unlike Barbie Land, though, the real Earth will live with the consequences of all this plastic, since, like humans, badly treated planets “only have one end,” too.
That’s why I think Gerwig’s film shows that the stakes go beyond Barbie herself and even contemporary womanhood. Gerwig’s invocation of the “plastics” of Los Angeles reminds us that the question of life is also one related to earth and environment. A plastic world is a dead world, not only because plastics aren’t alive but because they actually hasten the destruction of life on earth. The film counterintuitively ends with an uplifting message: Embracing the reality of death serves as an invitation to access and preserve life—ours and the earth’s—through our recognition of its frailty. Plastics pretty much “live” or, rather, exist, forever. We don’t, and our earth may not if we don’t change our ways.
Soon, we won’t be able to further ignore the reality of planet-level frailty, but while we’re still working up the courage to face the challenge of climate change (and tick-tock, people), perhaps a pink-hued, commercial film can give us a nudge. Turns out we should all take Existential Thoughts of Death Barbie as a model, because it is exactly those thoughts that clarify the preciousness of life—for us and our planet.
