Category: Literature

  • Is It Just Me, Or is Mary Shelley a Prophet?

    Rachelle Schwartz

    I will warn you now, this is not a safe space for AI users, supporters, and advancers. And to anyone who is not yet afraid of the future of AI, you will find this to be irritatingly melodramatic, and maybe it is. However, there is certainly something to be said for a technological innovation that changes our culture as drastically as artificial intelligence software has in such a short span of time, so I will say it as melodramatically as I please.

    So we have all seen Jurassic Park (1993), right? Well, do you remember that part where Jeff Goldblum’s sexy scientist character says, “God creates man. Man destroys God. Man creates dinosaurs.” Well the situation we are in with this sudden push for AI is pretty much that, just replace dinosaurs with artificial intelligence. Oh, and after, “Man creates artificial intelligence,” add that man also crowns artificial intelligence as king and sacrifices himself to his own creation. Okay so maybe it’s not exactly like Jurassic Park, but close enough. The threat posed by the widespread incorporation of artificial intelligence may not be as gruesome as being eaten by a T-rex, but it is certainly another example of the human quest to control and create life backfiring.

    Now this is where Mary Shelley comes in. Even if you haven’t read Frankenstein, you probably understand the basic premise: a young, passionate scientist galvanizes a corpse into life in order to find a cure for death. This is the first part of the prophecy. In order to find a remedy for using our own brains, we have invented artificial brains to do the work of thinking and writing for us. We are “curing” a tedious part of our human existence by replacing it with a soulless placeholder which is not actually capable of matching our capacities in thinking nor in writing, but is convincing enough to pass. Victor abandoned his monster, and maybe we should too, but I suppose abandonment didn’t exactly work out for him. Eventually, his creation grows too intelligent and driven, killing all of Victor’s loved ones in a quest for revenge that led to Victor’s own demise after a prolonged chase through the alps (spoiler alert).

    I am not saying AI is going to kill all of your friends and family, but you never know. Even if not, this new shortcut is certainly taking things from us that we value very deeply. Our ability to think, being one of them. Artificial intelligence technology was meant to be a servant that made the dull parts of the work easier. However, it has become a Frankenstein’s monster in its own right as it’s data base continually grows and it’s developers expand their reach beyond our control. The bigwigs behind things like ChatGPT, Grok, and a million others, are using our own laziness against us. New AI models are appearing everywhere, implemented in ways that insist upon their use. Worse still, it seems to require less and less insistence as the population becomes all too eager to find the easiest way around even the most mundane tasks.

    This tsunami of AI generation has flooded into every plane imaginable. From fiction novels to journalistic articles, and even personal transmissions. AI developers want us to use their technology to write our emails, finish our sentences, and create our social media posts for us. If we let the use of generative AI infiltrate all of the ways we express ourselves, the opportunity for human connection becomes even more limited. While AI was supposed to be our faithful servant, it feels we instead are the ones serving its already massive, unethically-sourced database, as well as the pockets of those behind it. There are real cases of AI developers feeding rare books to the AI to be digitally digested and destroyed. This sounds like dystopian science fiction, but it’s not. When we use AI, it’s algorithm processes our personal style into its ever-growing pool of information. Its developers exploit us for our human traits every time we type a prompt or response into one of their systems. These algorithms take everything human that we give it and jam it into a giant meat grinder that cranks out overused syntactical patterns and undistinguished correctness.

    Humans invented AI and marveled at their ability to create something so intelligent. Victor also marveled at the functioning of his patchwork cadaver before things got a little too real for him. The same humans have now found themselves subordinate to the creation which they gave power to by placing efficiency on a higher pedestal than progress. Who could have seen this coming? Mary Shelley, that’s who. It is the same creator/creation dynamic as we see in Frankenstein, only instead of being praised as a God as he intended, Victor was destroyed in the name of righteous retribution. But maybe that part of the prophecy is not so far off either.

    Victor Frankenstein becoming disgusted at his creation. Illustration from the frontispiece of the 1831 edition. Steel engraving (993 x 71mm) to the revised edition of Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, published by Colburn and Bentley, London 1831. The novel was first published in 1818.

    If you ask me, this is a more sinister sort of harm than what Frankenstein’s monster inflicted. The monster may have been gruesome, and murder is rarely justifiable, but at least he had a cause. At least he was seeking revenge with passion, something AI can never be programmed to understand. At least he was not forcing Victor to read AI slop Instagram captions. At least Victor was given the respect of being destroyed by something that had thoughts and feelings. If AI is to ever destroy mankind, it will be the result of statistical calculations. There will be no distressed monologues or pained wails wrenched from the depths of our destroyer’s being. There will be a cursor pretending to consider something and a corny one liner: “It’s not the age of AI, it’s the age of human annihilation.”

    Humans intend to usher in a future of ease and comfort in our tasks. They refer to AI as a “super intelligence.” An aid in our journey to superior consciousness. In reality, we are sacrificing everything from physical resources, human artifacts, personal histories, and our own lived experiences to the anonymous altar of something we created. In attempting to advance our species through unnaturally efficient means, we have rendered ourselves incompetent and useless. Who wants to hire a human when the newest AI model is so much cheaper, faster, and easier? Who wants to think for themselves when Grok can do it for them? Who wants to write a heartfelt message to the love of their life when ChatGPT is so good at sounding like it cares?

    But cutting out every meaningful part of the process is not efficiency. What is the point in producing all this text if what makes writing important is no longer valued? There can be no progress with generated text; it just recycles the few resources we don’t need to conserve: our thoughts, language, and expression. We are not ushering in a future of super intelligence; rather, it is a future in which everything that makes humanity outstanding is devalued. The only intelligence benefitting here is the software. Even those whose pockets are bursting at the seams from all the profits of generative artificial intelligence are not getting any smarter. The use of AI makes us more dependent and less experienced while it has the opposite effect on the algorithm.

    Like the monster, AI software seems to be inescapable, undefeatable, and more human than we intended. But the real kicker is that the humans behind AI are a lot like Victor. That is, they are much closer to the true villains of the story than the computers we so often blame. Human greed, be it for power, money, or fame, is what drives this surge in artificial intelligence, just as it drove Victor to generate life where it no longer belonged. AI itself does not have any sort of bloodlust or desire to destroy us. In fact, these algorithms have no desires at all. They are technical marvels, but they will never have the capacity to feel anything even remotely close to bloodlust. That is something unique to creatures of flesh, just as so many other things that we value in art and writing. Even the level of advancement we are reaching with AI can never compare with the miracle we are born with: consciousness. Artificial intelligence will never be better than you at writing because it cannot possibly think on the level that you can. The only people who want you to believe otherwise are those with something to gain.