Category: History

  • Is Nolan the Next Homer?

    Andrew A. Wade

    Over this last summer, Christopher Nolan debuted his adaptation of Homer’s The Odyssey. The story of one man’s journey home rocked the box office. The “epic” film brought this classic story to new generations of people throughout the world. The movie itself did well on popular reviewing sites like Rotten Tomatoes, receiving a 94% on the tomatometer.

    Does Nolan’s highly rated movie compare to Homer’s classic story? I think the answer is not as clear as you may believe it to be. To fairly compare the artists, it’s best to seek comparisons in how they affected the cultures of their day.

    One of the main ideas of both the book and the movie is how do we treat strangers who approach our home? This is “Zeus’ Law”. The idea was that you did not turn anyone away from your door, fed them, and prepared them for their travels, because they may be gods in disguise. This ideology united an entire population of people after Homer started reciting his poems.

    Because of Nolan, The Odyssey, once again, united a whole new population of people. I witnessed families, even extended families, travel together to go see this movie. I am not talking about simple ten-minute drives. No. Multiple hour travels, grueling odysseys, in their own right, were taking place. I was one of these people. After spending four and a half hours driving to Rochester, New York, I had to really exhibit a lot of strength in Zeus’ law to keep my friends in the vehicle, rather than on the side of I-90. This really begs to question: what do we call home? For me, this reaching out and having community, bonding, is our generation’s law.

    On top of forming bonds during road travel, there was a lot more unifying outside of the vehicle. Homer’s influence did not just affect the people in his 2014 Ford Fusion. He unified an entire nation under the ideologies he bestowed upon the epic. Greece was not a unified state, but, rather, a collection of peoples with differing values and beliefs. His story, essentially (providing cliff notes here), unified the peoples of Greece under one clear set of beliefs. If he could do that on a stage in recitation, imagine what he could do with social media. Surely, Nolan could not have done that with his movie. But wait. Why were people traveling so far to see a movie they could watch at a theater closer to home? People invested and believed in IMAX 70mm film. Nolan got me hook, line, and sinker. Seeing this level of movie production on real film was both nostalgic and immersive. Everyone in that theatre came for one thing: a shared experience. You could feel the intensity of the room when Odysseus’ men attacked Polyphemus. It rivaled the modern live theatre experience, because people had a passion for what they were viewing. Complete strangers came together, traveling hours upon hours, to unite under one human experience. Did he unite an entire nation? No, but he did unite the movie going population to believe in classic film again.

    We live in a wonderful age of technological advancement that makes things like Avengers possible to see on the big screen; however, this advancement also tends to negate the need for human connection. As a Marvel Cinematic Universe super nerd, I greatly appreciate these advances. However, do we lose the humanity behind classic storytelling with the overuse of CGI? When Homer was telling this story, he did not have computers to assist with his recitations. His poems were human, physical, spontaneous. That would have been something to experience. Nolan attempted to be as down to earth as he physically could. I mean that quite literally. For much of the film, Nolan was literally on location sailing the ocean. Furthermore, this also means that the crew were all together with him. You ask: how could watching a finished, polished product be near as good as Homer’s original tale? I answer through the lens of the cast. Any interview you look up, you see how close they all had become. Why? What is different from any other movie set? They endured harsh filming conditions together. Everyone was experiencing something real. Their journey during the making of The Odyssey was in and of itself an odyssey.  From Matt Damon to one of the two thousand extras, everyone was on an equal playing field. No computer can replicate the bonds that were formed in front of our eyes. You only get that kind of tangible experience in something human, not computer or AI generated.

    So, is Nolan a next level creator with a rivalry to Homer? Maybe? He truly created something marvelous that reinvigorated the lives of movie goers. He brought up expectations for all future movies. However, it is Homer’s story that has lasted this long to get adapted by Nolan. So, I leave it to you. Does our generation have their Odyssey?

  • Party Like It’s 5th Century BC

    Qwen Wagstaff

    Ancient Greek parties started like any other party: People getting together to drink and celebrate. Those parties became large-scale, multi-day parties. The biggest rager was the Dionysia party in Athens. People would come from all over Greece just to attend. At the time, moving between states in Greece was exceedingly rare. Each state produced its own culture and way of life. They went to war with each other quite often, so chances to meet people from a different state were very rare, especially for women. Public streets became full of music and laughter. Wine gaskets mixed with honey and water were laid around the festival for partygoers to enjoy. It would be a warm spring week in Athens in the middle of April when the party was traditionally held. They only had fire to see those nights, but surely more stars than you would see now. The hope of these gatherings was to share the love of music and thought- transcending arbitrary barriers and looking past another person’s way of life to just have a fun time. 

    Every culture around the world has their own practice for the cultivation of alcohol or drugs and the desire to party. While it is not always glamorous, it connects all cultures around the world. But for unexplainable reasons, Generation Z has started partying less. I am not a sociologist, and I cannot tell you why. If I were a historian looking back on us, I would be incredibly surprised to find out we do not want to drink. In a time of economic instability, political unrest, and general unhappiness, I assume more people want to forget about the outside world. People clearly started this ritual habit long ago, so why is it something people would rather not do?  

    Perhaps there is something to be learned from their party way of life and see what we may be missing out on. The “Great Dionysia” is named after the god of wine and, as expected, most of the festival was centered around drunkenness. Although it is said to be in worship of the god Dionysus, it would be easy to surmise they might have also been doing it for fun or to release inhibitions. If you imagine yourself as a young partygoer. You come in and see a brand-new comedy while enjoying wine and food with your friends, with a full chorus around singing for Dionysus. Large barrels of wine are situated around for everyone to get a drink if they needed, filling the air with sweet grapes and the honey they used to sweeten them. Conversation areas are scattered throughout; that way you can have proper conversation about the different festivities you experienced. And that’s where real emphasis is put. These experiences are for your conversation and education. Formal education was not something normal for ancient Greeks and especially women. And here you have the freedom to openly learn and add analysis to what you say. It’s an open space where everyone is aware these ideas are to be taken seriously at all times. It is okay to be silly or have crazy ideas. It gives you air to explore a different way of thinking.  

    Terracotta column-krater (bowl for mixing wine and water)
    Attributed to the Group of Boston 00.348
    ca. 360–350 BCE

    This gave way to the encouragement of social relationships. Often relationships are confined to occupation or proximity. But with thousands of people all gathering at one place, the chance to meet with someone who shares a different worldview than you is drastically higher. At a place where the emphasis is put on you having creative and new conversations and being introduced to new people, it is a perfect hub for groundbreaking ideas. Added to the atmosphere of education, it becomes an open-minded sphere for discovery. 

    As I look throughout history at the way our partying has evolved, I do not see much difference: you’re drinking, listening to music, and talking. No matter where you look in time or space, everyone is partying like its 5th century BC: A shared experience between all of humanity.  

    But not my generation. There’s a growing rise in not wanting to be social. This seems counterintuitive; we are social creatures. At our hearts, we are animals who come together to create larger ideas. No city, party, or government is formed without social conversation. Yet we have been running from each other recently and becoming more divided. Fear compounds on fear; it could be a fear of the outside world or a fear of the outside world perceiving you. But something is creating this circumstance in which young people do not want to socialize with each other.  

    These days it is even easier to have your own echo chamber and feel safe in the warmth of it, never daring to leave. However, I do believe faith can compound faith as well. That people can show each other that it is okay to have conversations with unlike-minded people. Share in new creative media and have space to discuss without judgement. The Great Dionysia gave peace to people and space to share in their differences and discoveries. Perhaps that is what we are missing out on.  

    The Ancient Greeks and the Importance of Education | Being Human Festival, www.beinghumanfestival.org/news/ancient-greeks-and-importance-education.   

    “Dionysos Cult 1.” DIONYSUS CULT 1 – Ancient Greek Religion, www.theoi.com/Cult/DionysosCult.html.